- Jack Clark,
- Jackson, Bo
- Jackson, Danny
- Jackson, Reggie
- Jenkins, Fergie
- Jennings, Desmond
- Jeter, Derek
- Johnson, Josh
- Johnson, Randy
- Jones, Andruw
- Jones, Chipper
- Jordan, Ricky
- Jordan, Brian
- Jordan, Michael
- Joyner, Wally
- Jr. Griffy, Ken
- Justice, Dave
- Justice, David