- Saberhagen, Bret
- Sabo, Chris
- Sakic, Joe
- Salmon, Tim
- Samuel, Juan
- Sandberg, Ryne
- Sandberg Ryne,
- Sanders, Deion
- Santiago, Benito
- Sax, Steve
- Schilling, Curt
- Schmidt, Mike
- Schmidt. Mike,
- Scott, Tony
- Searcy, Steve
- Seaver, Tom
- Segui, David
- Seitzer, Kevin
- Sexson, Richie
- Sheffield, Gary
- Sierra, Ruben
- Singleton, Ken
- Skinner, Joel
- Slaughter, Enos
- Smith, Ozzie
- Smith Ozzie,
- Snider, Duke
- Snow, JT
- Snyder, Chris
- Sosa, Sammy
- Spillner, Dan
- Splittorf, Paul
- SS11 Dunston, Shawon
- SS15 Evans, Dwight
- SS18 Murphy, Dale
- SS20 Winfield, Dave
- SS23 Fisk, Carlton
- SS24 Virgil, Ozzie
- SS26 Gubicza, Mark
- SS26 Reuschel, Rick
- SS28 Fernandez, Sid
- SS3 Hernandez, Keith
- SS31 Eckersley, Dennis
- SS36 McGwire, Mark
- SS37 Randolph, Willie
- SS4 Herr, Tom
- SS42,
- SS42 Molitor, Paul
- SS44 Ripken Jr., Cal
- SS51 Henderson, Rickey
- SS60 Hershiser, Orel
- SS61 Browning, Tom
- SS63 Langston, Mark
- SS66 Myers, Randy
- SS67 Checklist,
- SS8 Johnson, Howard
- St. James, Lyn
- Stan Musial,
- Stapleton, Dave
- Stargell, Willie
- Steinbach, Terry
- Stewart, Dave
- Stewart, Shannon
- Stone, Steve
- Stottlemyre, Todd
- Strange, Curtis
- Strawberry, Darryl
- Sutter, Bruce
- Sutton, Don
- Suzuki, Ichiro