- Padres, San Diego
- Pagliarulo, Mike
- Palmeiro, Rafael
- Palmer, Dean
- Pankovits, Jim
- Park, Chan Ho
- Parker, Dave
- Parrish, Lance
- Parrish, Larry
- Pasqua, Dan
- Pat Borders,
- Patterson, Corey
- Patterson, Ken
- Pedroia, Dustin
- Pena, Tony
- Pender, Matt
- Perez, Timo
- Perez, Tony
- Pettis, Gary
- Piazza, Mike
- Pierre, Juan
- Podsednik, Scott
- Pridie, Jason
- Pronger, Chris
- Puckett, Kirby
- Pujols, Luis
- Pujols, Albert